| | | Cheyney wins the toss and defers choice to the second half |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey30 | CHEY ball on CHEY30. |
| | | Tyler Wilkinson kickoff 55 yards to the MILL15, Matt Egenrieder return 18 yards to the MILL33 (Maurice Jones;Thomas Stewart). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill33 | Mike Jones rush for 6 yards to the MILL39 (Bryon Payne;Corey Brown). |
| Mill | 2-4 | at Mill39 | Brandon Gunn rush for 4 yards to the MILL43, 1ST DOWN MILL (Maurice Jones;Tim Hume). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill43 | Mike Jones rush for loss of 3 yards to the MILL40 (Bryon Payne). |
| Mill | 2-13 | at Mill40 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete to Matt Egenrieder. |
| Mill | 3-13 | at Mill40 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete to Mike Jones (Maurice Jones), PENALTY MILL holding declined. |
| Mill | 4-13 | at Mill40 | Jeff Lawson punt 53 yards to the CHEY7, downed. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 7 yards, TOP 02:06 |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey07 | CHEYNEY drive start at 12:54. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey07 | Chris Anderson pass incomplete, QB hurry by Chad Miller. |
| Chey | 2-10 | at Chey07 | Chris Anderson rush for 7 yards to the CHEY14 (Jeff Longley). |
| Chey | 3-3 | at Chey14 | Marcus Jones rush for 1 yard to the CHEY15 (Chad Miller). |
| Chey | 4-2 | at Chey15 | B. Buchanon punt 15 yards to the CHEY30, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:37 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Chey30 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 11:17. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Chey30 | Mike Jones rush for 27 yards to the CHEY3, 1ST DOWN MILL (Bryon Payne;Stan Banks). |
| Mill | 1-G | at Chey03 | Fateen Brown rush for 2 yards to the CHEY1 (Brandon Reed;Joe Winn). |
| Mill | 2-G | at Chey01 | Bill Shirk rush for loss of 1 yard to the CHEY2. |
| Mill | 3-G | at Chey02 | Bill Shirk pass complete to Jeff Longley for 2 yards to the CHEY0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:31. |
| | | Anthony Kassab kick attempt good. |
| | | Millersville 7, Cheyney 0 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 30 yards, TOP 01:52 |
| | | Anthony Kassab kickoff 57 yards to the CHEY13, Stan Banks return 7 yards to the CHEY20 (Daniel Jones). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey20 | CHEYNEY drive start at 09:25. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey20 | Dominic Crowell rush for 6 yards to the CHEY26 (Jeff Longley). |
| Chey | 2-4 | at Chey26 | Chris Anderson rush for no gain to the CHEY26 (Owen King;Jeff Longley). |
| Chey | 3-4 | at Chey26 | Chris Anderson pass complete to Julius Faison for 14 yards to the CHEY40, 1ST DOWN CHEY, out-of-bounds (Matt Sutjak). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey40 | John Newman rush for 1 yard to the CHEY41 (Jacob Haines). |
| Chey | 2-9 | at Chey41 | Marcus Jones rush for 4 yards to the CHEY45 (Pat Maloney). |
| Chey | 3-5 | at Chey45 | Marcus Jones rush for 15 yards to the MILL40, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Gary Tillman;Matt Sutjak), PENALTY MILL personal foul (Shane Gross) 15 yards to the MILL25, 1ST DOWN CHEY. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Mill25 | 1st and 10. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Mill25 | Dominic Crowell rush for loss of 3 yards to the MILL28 (Shane Gross). |
| Chey | 2-13 | at Mill28 | Chris Anderson pass incomplete to John Newman. |
| Chey | 3-13 | at Mill28 | Chris Anderson pass complete to Prince Stewar for 19 yards to the MILL9, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Shane Gross). |
| Chey | 1-G | at Mill09 | Marcus Jones rush for 3 yards to the MILL6 (Zack Riley;Pat Maloney). |
| Chey | 2-G | at Mill06 | Chris Anderson pass incomplete to Prince Stewar (John Wynder), QB hurry by Zack Riley. |
| Chey | 3-G | at Mill06 | Marcus Jones rush for 1 yard to the MILL5 (Chad Miller;Owen King). |
| Chey | 4-G | at Mill05 | Tyler Wilkinson field goal attempt from 22 GOOD, clock 03:07. |
| | | Millersville 7, Cheyney 3 |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 75 yards, TOP 06:23 |
| | | Tyler Wilkinson kickoff 58 yards to the MILL12, Matt Egenrieder return 8 yards to the MILL20 (Adam Madden;Thomas Stewart). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill20 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 03:02. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill20 | Mike Jones rush for 5 yards to the MILL25 (Tim Hume;Frank Lyburn). |
| Mill | 2-5 | at Mill25 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete to Dominic Sanders (B. Buchanon). |
| Mill | 3-5 | at Mill25 | Bill Shirk pass complete to Brandon Gunn for 18 yards to the MILL43, 1ST DOWN MILL. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill43 | Mike Jones rush for 6 yards to the MILL49 (Bryon Payne). |
| Mill | 2-4 | at Mill49 | Bill Shirk pass complete to Dominic Sanders for 3 yards to the CHEY48, out-of-bounds. |
| Mill | 3-1 | at Chey48 | Mike Jones rush for 3 yards to the CHEY45, 1ST DOWN MILL (Frank Lyburn). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Chey45 | Bill Shirk pass complete to Matt Egenrieder for 29 yards to the CHEY16, 1ST DOWN MILL, out-of-bounds (B. Buchanon;Maurice Jones). |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 64 yards, TOP 04:23 |
| | | Millersville 7, Cheyney 3 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Chey16 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Chey16 | Mike Jones rush for loss of 2 yards to the CHEY18 (Thomas Stewart). |
| Mill | 2-12 | at Chey18 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete to Jamal Smith. |
| Mill | 3-12 | at Chey18 | Bill Shirk sacked for loss of 4 yards to the CHEY22 (Tim Hume). |
| Mill | 4-16 | at Chey22 | Anthony Kassab field goal attempt from 39 MISSED - wide left, spot at CHEY22, clock 13:39. |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 58 yards, TOP 04:23 |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey22 | CHEYNEY drive start at 13:39. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey22 | PENALTY MILL offside (Zack Riley) 5 yards to the CHEY27. |
| Chey | 1-5 | at Chey27 | Chris Anderson rush for loss of 4 yards to the CHEY23, fumble by Chris Anderson recovered by MILL Matt Sutjak at CHEY18, Matt Sutjak for 7 yards to the CHEY11 (Chris Anderson). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 00:14 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Chey11 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 13:25, MILL ball on CHEY11. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Chey11 | Mike Jones rush for loss of 2 yards to the CHEY13 (Tim Hume). |
| Mill | 2-12 | at Chey13 | Bill Shirk pass complete to Jamal Smith for 13 yards to the CHEY0, 1ST DOWN MILL, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:48. |
| | | Anthony Kassab kick attempt good. |
| | | Millersville 14, Cheyney 3 |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 11 yards, TOP 00:44 |
| | | Anthony Kassab kickoff 57 yards to the CHEY13, Stan Banks return 12 yards to the CHEY25 (Gilbert Ramos). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey25 | CHEYNEY drive start at 12:41. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey25 | Marcus Jones rush for 6 yards to the CHEY31 (Jeff Longley). |
| Chey | 2-4 | at Chey31 | Marcus Jones rush for 4 yards to the CHEY35, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Donald Vodopija). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey35 | Marcus Jones rush for 11 yards to the CHEY46, 1ST DOWN CHEY (A. Brown-Barnes). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey46 | Marcus Jones rush for 5 yards to the MILL49 (Donald Vodopija). |
| Chey | 2-5 | at Mill49 | James Ramsey pass incomplete (Shane Gross). |
| Chey | 3-5 | at Mill49 | Julius Faison rush for 7 yards to the MILL42, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Rees Judge). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Mill42 | Marcus Jones rush for 4 yards to the MILL38 (Matt Marcinek;Pat Maloney), PENALTY CHEY IS 5 yards to the MILL47, NO PLAY. |
| Chey | 1-15 | at Mill47 | James Ramsey rush for 3 yards to the MILL44 (Lee Hoover). |
| Chey | 2-12 | at Mill44 | James Ramsey rush for 2 yards to the MILL42 (Shane Gross). |
| Chey | 3-10 | at Mill42 | James Ramsey pass complete to John Newman for 4 yards to the MILL38 (Ryan Christian). |
| Chey | 4-6 | at Mill38 | James Ramsey pass complete to John Newman for 3 yards to the MILL35 (Brian Knell). |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 40 yards, TOP 05:33 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill35 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 07:08. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill35 | Mike Jones rush for no gain to the MILL35 (Bryon Payne;Corey Brown). |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill35 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete to Matt Egenrieder. |
| Mill | 3-10 | at Mill35 | Bill Shirk rush for 12 yards to the MILL47, 1ST DOWN MILL, out-of-bounds. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill47 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete to Fateen Brown, QB hurry by Frank Lyburn. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill47 | Mike Jones rush for 16 yards to the CHEY37, 1ST DOWN MILL (Bryon Payne). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Chey37 | Mike Jones rush for 1 yard to the CHEY36 (Byron Void). |
| Mill | 2-9 | at Chey36 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete to Jamal Smith (Carl Meeks). |
| Mill | 3-9 | at Chey36 | Bill Shirk sacked for loss of 16 yards to the MILL48 (Ariene Gardner). |
| Mill | 4-25 | at Mill48 | Jeff Lawson punt 49 yards to the CHEY3, downed. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 13 yards, TOP 03:28 |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey03 | CHEYNEY drive start at 03:40. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey03 | Marcus Jones rush for 3 yards to the CHEY6 (A. Brown-Barnes;Pat Maloney). |
| Chey | 2-7 | at Chey06 | Dominic Crowell rush for 10 yards to the CHEY16, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Jamie Hoffman). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey16 | Marcus Jones rush for 4 yards to the CHEY20 (Gary Tillman). |
| Chey | 2-6 | at Chey20 | Marcus Jones rush for 3 yards to the CHEY23 (Owen King). |
| Chey | 3-3 | at Chey23 | John Newman rush for 77 yards to the MILL0, 1ST DOWN CHEY, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:28. |
| | | Tyler Wilkinson kick attempt good. |
| | | Millersville 14, Cheyney 10 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 97 yards, TOP 02:21 |
| | | Tyler Wilkinson kickoff 51 yards to the MILL19, Matt Egenrieder return 46 yards to the CHEY35 (Brandon Collins;Lonnell Wilson). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Chey35 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 01:19. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Chey35 | PENALTY CHEY substitution infraction 5 yards to the CHEY30. |
| Mill | 1-5 | at Chey30 | Bill Shirk pass complete to Jamal Smith for 15 yards to the CHEY15, 1ST DOWN MILL. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Chey15 | Bill Shirk sacked for loss of 9 yards to the CHEY24 (Tim Hume). |
| Mill | 2-19 | at Chey24 | Timeout Millersville, clock 01:00. |
| Mill | 2-19 | at Chey24 | Bill Shirk pass complete to Mike Jones for 5 yards to the CHEY19 (Thomas Stewart). |
| Mill | 3-14 | at Chey19 | Timeout Millersville, clock 00:46. |
| Mill | 3-14 | at Chey19 | Bill Shirk sacked for loss of 6 yards to the CHEY25 (Tim Hume). |
| Mill | 4-20 | at Chey25 | Timeout Millersville, clock 00:36. |
| Mill | 4-20 | at Chey25 | Anthony Kassab field goal attempt from 42 BLOCKED, recovered by CHEY CU WOLVES at CHEY25 spot at CHEY25, clock 00:31 (blocked by Carl Meeks), CU WOLVES for no gain to the CHEY25. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 10 yards, TOP 00:48 |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey25 | CHEYNEY drive start at 00:31. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey25 | CU WOLVES rush for loss of 2 yards to the CHEY23. |
| Chey | 2-12 | at Chey23 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 00:31 |
| | | Millersville 14, Cheyney 10 |
| Chey | 2-12 | at Chey23 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, MILL ball on MILL30. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 00:31 |
| | | Anthony Kassab kickoff 53 yards to the CHEY17, Stan Banks return 17 yards to the CHEY34 (Lee Hoover), PENALTY CHEY holding (Robert Tolbert) 9 yards to the CHEY25, 1st and 10, CHEY ball on CHEY25. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey25 | CHEYNEY drive start at 14:54. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey25 | Marcus Jones rush for no gain to the CHEY25 (Chad Miller;Zack Riley). |
| Chey | 2-10 | at Chey25 | Dominic Crowell rush for loss of 1 yard to the CHEY24, out-of-bounds (Rees Judge). |
| Chey | 3-11 | at Chey24 | Marcus Jones rush for 8 yards to the CHEY32 (Jeff Longley). |
| Chey | 4-3 | at Chey32 | Tyler Wilkinson punt 31 yards to the MILL37, Matt Egenrieder return 9 yards to the MILL46, PENALTY MILL holding declined, PENALTY MILL IB 10 yards to the MILL36, 1st and 10, MILL ball on MILL36. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 7 yards, TOP 01:56 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill36 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 12:58. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill36 | Mike Jones rush for no gain to the MILL36 (Joe Winn). |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill36 | Bill Shirk pass complete to Jamal Smith for 8 yards to the MILL44 (Maurice Jones). |
| Mill | 3-2 | at Mill44 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete to Matt Egenrieder (B. Buchanon). |
| Mill | 4-2 | at Mill44 | Jeff Lawson punt 46 yards to the CHEY10, fair catch by Stan Banks. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:31 |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey10 | CHEYNEY drive start at 11:27. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey10 | James Ramsey pass complete to Prince Stewar for 7 yards to the CHEY17 (John Wynder). |
| Chey | 2-3 | at Chey17 | Marcus Jones rush for 14 yards to the CHEY31, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Gary Tillman;Pat Maloney). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey31 | James Ramsey pass complete to Dominic Crowell for 4 yards to the CHEY35. |
| Chey | 2-6 | at Chey35 | Julius Faison rush for 3 yards to the CHEY38 (Jeff Longley). |
| Chey | 3-3 | at Chey38 | John Newman rush for 5 yards to the CHEY43, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Gary Tillman). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey43 | Marcus Jones rush for 2 yards to the CHEY45 (Pat Maloney). |
| Chey | 2-8 | at Chey45 | Marcus Jones rush for 3 yards to the CHEY48 (Shane Gross). |
| Chey | 3-5 | at Chey48 | James Ramsey pass complete to Travis Taltoan for 12 yards to the MILL40, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Jeff Longley;Gary Tillman). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Mill40 | John Newman rush for 1 yard to the MILL39 (Matt Sutjak;Shane Gross). |
| Chey | 2-9 | at Mill39 | John Newman rush for no gain to the MILL39 (Pat Maloney;Chad Miller). |
| Chey | 3-9 | at Mill39 | Dominic Crowell rush for 2 yards to the MILL37 (Gary Tillman). |
| Chey | 4-7 | at Mill37 | Chris Anderson pass incomplete to Travis Taltoan (Rees Judge). |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 53 yards, TOP 07:28 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill37 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 03:59. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill37 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete, QB hurry by Corey Brown. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill37 | Bill Shirk pass complete to Matt Egenrieder for 13 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN MILL. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill50 | Mike Jones rush for 3 yards to the CHEY47 (Bryon Payne;Byron Void). |
| Mill | 2-7 | at Chey47 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete to Dominic Sanders, dropped pass. |
| Mill | 3-7 | at Chey47 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete to Dominic Sanders, dropped pass. |
| Mill | 4-7 | at Chey47 | Jeff Lawson punt 33 yards to the CHEY14, fair catch by Stan Banks, PENALTY MILL kick catching interference 15 yards to the CHEY29, 1st and 10, CHEY ball on CHEY29. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 16 yards, TOP 01:35 |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey29 | CHEYNEY drive start at 02:24. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey29 | Dominic Crowell rush for loss of 3 yards to the CHEY26 (Shane Gross). |
| Chey | 2-13 | at Chey26 | Marcus Jones rush for 23 yards to the CHEY49, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Matt Sutjak;Gary Tillman). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey49 | Julius Faison rush for 2 yards to the MILL49 (Matt Marcinek;Zack Riley). |
| Chey | 2-8 | at Mill49 | James Ramsey rush for 6 yards to the MILL43 (Pat Maloney;Rees Judge). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 28 yards, TOP 06:40 |
| | | Millersville 14, Cheyney 10 |
| Chey | 3-2 | at Mill43 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Chey | 3-2 | at Mill43 | Marcus Jones rush for 4 yards to the MILL39, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Jeff Longley). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Mill39 | John Newman rush for 3 yards to the MILL36 (Pat Maloney;Zack Riley). |
| Chey | 2-7 | at Mill36 | Marcus Jones rush for 6 yards to the MILL30 (Pat Cantrell). |
| Chey | 3-1 | at Mill30 | Marcus Jones rush for 6 yards to the MILL24, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Ryan Christian). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Mill24 | Marcus Jones rush for 5 yards to the MILL19 (Ryan Christian). |
| Chey | 2-5 | at Mill19 | Julius Faison rush for 2 yards to the MILL17 (Shane Gross). |
| Chey | 3-3 | at Mill17 | Marcus Jones rush for 2 yards to the MILL15 (Ryan Christian). |
| Chey | 4-1 | at Mill15 | Timeout Millersville, clock 11:00. |
| Chey | 4-1 | at Mill15 | Dominic Crowell rush for 4 yards to the MILL11, PENALTY CHEY holding 10 yards to the MILL21. |
| Chey | 4-7 | at Mill21 | 4th and 7. |
| Chey | 4-7 | at Mill21 | Tyler Wilkinson field goal attempt from 37 GOOD, clock 10:50. |
| | | Millersville 14, Cheyney 13 |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 50 yards, TOP 06:40 |
| | | Tyler Wilkinson kickoff 54 yards to the MILL16, Matt Egenrieder return 21 yards to the MILL37 (Julius Faison;Adam Madden). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill37 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 10:44. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill37 | Mike Jones rush for 5 yards to the MILL42 (Maurice Jones;Brandon Reed). |
| Mill | 2-5 | at Mill42 | Mike Jones rush for 1 yard to the MILL43 (Brandon Reed). |
| Mill | 3-4 | at Mill43 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete to Dominic Sanders. |
| Mill | 4-4 | at Mill43 | Jeff Lawson punt 41 yards to the CHEY16, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:25 |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey16 | CHEYNEY drive start at 09:19. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey16 | Dominic Crowell rush for 1 yard to the CHEY17, out-of-bounds (Brian Knell). |
| Chey | 2-9 | at Chey17 | Marcus Jones rush for 12 yards to the CHEY29, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Shane Gross). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey29 | James Ramsey rush for 5 yards to the CHEY34 (Brian Knell). |
| Chey | 2-5 | at Chey34 | Marcus Jones rush for 14 yards to the CHEY48, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Matt Sutjak;Pat Maloney). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey48 | Julius Faison rush for 3 yards to the MILL49 (Pat Maloney;Owen King). |
| Chey | 2-7 | at Mill49 | James Ramsey rush for 1 yard to the MILL48 (A. Brown-Barnes;Jacob Haines). |
| Chey | 3-6 | at Mill48 | James Ramsey pass complete to Travis Taltoan for loss of 2 yards to the 50 yardline (John Wynder), QB hurry by Pat Maloney. |
| Chey | 4-8 | at Chey50 | Tyler Wilkinson punt 50 yards to the MILL0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 34 yards, TOP 04:28 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill20 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 04:51. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill20 | Bill Shirk rush for no gain to the MILL20 (Ben Thompson). |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill20 | Bill Shirk pass complete to Jamal Smith for 51 yards to the CHEY29, 1ST DOWN MILL (B. Buchanon). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Chey29 | Fateen Brown rush for 5 yards to the CHEY24 (Byron Void). |
| Mill | 2-5 | at Chey24 | Bill Shirk pass complete to Jamal Smith for 22 yards to the CHEY2, 1ST DOWN MILL (Maurice Jones;B. Buchanon). |
| Mill | 1-G | at Chey02 | Timeout Cheyney, clock 03:04. |
| Mill | 1-G | at Chey02 | Fateen Brown rush for loss of 2 yards to the CHEY4 (Frank Lyburn;Ed Wells Jr). |
| Mill | 2-G | at Chey04 | Timeout Millersville, clock 02:22. |
| Mill | 2-G | at Chey04 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete to Jamal Smith. |
| Mill | 3-G | at Chey04 | Bill Shirk sacked for loss of 7 yards to the CHEY11 (Frank Lyburn;Brandon Reed). |
| Mill | 4-G | at Chey11 | Timeout Cheyney, clock 02:08. |
| Mill | 4-G | at Chey11 | Anthony Kassab field goal attempt from 28 GOOD, clock 02:05. |
| | | Millersville 17, Cheyney 13 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 69 yards, TOP 02:53 |
| | | Anthony Kassab kickoff 50 yards to the CHEY20, Stan Banks return 10 yards to the CHEY30 (Gilbert Ramos;Daniel Jones). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey30 | CHEYNEY drive start at 01:58. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey30 | Chris Anderson pass complete to Prince Stewar for 28 yards to the MILL42, 1ST DOWN CHEY, out-of-bounds. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Mill42 | Chris Anderson pass incomplete to John Newman. |
| Chey | 2-10 | at Mill42 | Chris Anderson pass incomplete to Adam Madden. |
| Chey | 3-10 | at Mill42 | Chris Anderson pass complete to John Newman for 1 yard to the MILL41 (Matt Sutjak). |
| Chey | 4-9 | at Mill41 | Timeout Cheyney, clock 01:26. |
| Chey | 4-9 | at Mill41 | Chris Anderson pass incomplete to Prince Stewar, PENALTY MILL pass interference (John Wynder) 6 yards to the MILL35, 1ST DOWN CHEY, NO PLAY. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Mill35 | Chris Anderson pass incomplete, QB hurry by Pat Cantrell. |
| Chey | 2-10 | at Mill35 | Chris Anderson pass complete to Dominic Crowell for 17 yards to the MILL18, 1ST DOWN CHEY. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Mill18 | Chris Anderson pass incomplete. |
| Chey | 2-10 | at Mill18 | Chris Anderson pass complete to Travis Taltoan for 9 yards to the MILL9. |
| Chey | 3-1 | at Mill09 | Chris Anderson pass incomplete. |
| Chey | 4-1 | at Mill09 | Marcus Jones rush for 1 yard to the MILL8, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Jacob Haines;Jeff Longley). |
| Chey | 1-G | at Mill08 | Chris Anderson pass incomplete to Prince Stewar, PENALTY MILL pass interference (John Wynder) 6 yards to the MILL2, 1ST DOWN CHEY, NO PLAY. |
| Chey | 1-G | at Mill02 | Chris Anderson rush for 2 yards to the MILL0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:30. |
| | | Tyler Wilkinson kick attempt good. |
| | | Cheyney 20, Millersville 17 |
| Chey | 1-G | at Chey30 | PENALTY MILL unsportsmanlike conduct (Shane Gross) 15 yards to the CHEY45, clock 00:30. |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 70 yards, TOP 01:28 |
| | | Tyler Wilkinson kickoff 55 yards to the MILL0, touchback. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill20 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 00:30. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill20 | Bill Shirk sacked for loss of 3 yards to the MILL17 (Byron Void;Joe Winn). |
| Mill | 2-13 | at Mill17 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete to Fateen Brown (Frank Lyburn). |
| Mill | 3-13 | at Mill17 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete to Jamal Smith (Carl Meeks). |
| Mill | 4-13 | at Mill17 | Bill Shirk pass incomplete. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 3 yards, TOP 00:30 |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Mill17 | CHEYNEY drive start at 00:00. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Mill17 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Cheyney 20, Millersville 17 |