| | | Seton Hill wins the toss and defers to the second half |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu35 | SHU ball on SHU35. |
| | | Santiago Henao kickoff 62 yards to the MILL3, Christian Kemp return 58 yards to the SHU39 (Santiago Henao). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu39 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete to Blake Cahill (Richardo Housen). |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Shu39 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Christian Kemp for 39 yards to the SHU0, 1ST DOWN MILL, TOUCHDOWN, clock 14:35. |
| | | Evan Stahl kick attempt good. |
| | | Millersville 7, Seton Hill 0 |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 39 yards, TOP 00:39 |
| | | Evan Stahl kickoff 57 yards to the SHU8, M. B-Ferguson return 57 yards to the MILL35 (J. Robinson;Nii Kotei Nikoi). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill35 | SETON HILL drive start at 14:21. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill35 | Jarvis McClam rush for 2 yards to the MILL33 (Logan Kinser). |
| Shu | 2-8 | at Mill33 | C. Strong pass complete to Ty George for 8 yards to the MILL25, 1ST DOWN SHU (Rob Varner). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill25 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Jarvis McClam, dropped pass. |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Mill25 | Jarvis McClam rush for 25 yards to the MILL0, 1ST DOWN SHU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 13:23. |
| | | Santiago Henao kick attempt good. |
| | | Seton Hill 7, Millersville 7 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 35 yards, TOP 01:04 |
| | | Santiago Henao kickoff 64 yards to the MILL1, Christian Kemp return 19 yards to the MILL20 (Dexter Williams). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill20 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 13:17. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill20 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete to Phil Overton. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill20 | J.J. Paige rush for no gain to the MILL20 (Tim Johnson). |
| Mill | 3-10 | at Mill20 | J.J. Paige sacked for loss of 7 yards to the MILL13 (N. Boynton;J. Thompson). |
| Mill | 4-17 | at Mill13 | Evan Stahl punt 40 yards to the SHU47, Jarvis McClam return 0 yards to the SHU47, fumble by Jarvis McClam recovered by SHU Jarvis McClam at SHU47. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 7 yards, TOP 01:24 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu47 | SETON HILL drive start at 11:53. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu47 | C. Strong pass complete to M. B-Ferguson for 14 yards to the MILL39, 1ST DOWN SHU, out-of-bounds. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill39 | C. Strong pass complete to Norman Darden for 8 yards to the MILL31 (Alpha Khan). |
| Shu | 2-2 | at Mill31 | Jarvis McClam rush for 3 yards to the MILL28, 1ST DOWN SHU (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill28 | C. Strong pass complete to Jarvis McClam for 16 yards to the MILL12, 1ST DOWN SHU (P.J. Santos). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill12 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Ty George (J. Satterfield). |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Mill12 | C. Strong pass complete to Norman Darden for 8 yards to the MILL4, fumble forced by Alpha Khan, fumble by Norman Darden recovered by MILL J. Robinson at MILL4, J. Robinson for 20 yards to the MILL24, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 49 yards, TOP 01:56 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill24 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 09:57, MILL ball on MILL24. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill24 | Tony Staffieri rush for 3 yards to the MILL27 (K. Petit-Frere;Tim Johnson). |
| Mill | 2-7 | at Mill27 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Kevin Wiggins for no gain to the MILL27 (David Gutzmore). |
| Mill | 3-7 | at Mill27 | J.J. Paige rush for 1 yard to the MILL28 (J. Thompson), PENALTY SHU unsportsmanlike conduct (J. Thompson) 15 yards to the MILL43, 1ST DOWN MILL. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill43 | 1st and 10. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill43 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins, dropped pass. |
| | | #54 ejected for conduct foul |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill43 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete to Christian Kemp. |
| Mill | 3-10 | at Mill43 | J.J. Paige sacked for loss of 4 yards to the MILL39 (Tim Johnson), PENALTY MILL holding declined. |
| Mill | 4-14 | at Mill39 | Evan Stahl punt 31 yards to the SHU30, fair catch by Jarvis McClam. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 15 yards, TOP 02:16 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu30 | SETON HILL drive start at 07:41. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu30 | Jarvis McClam rush for 7 yards to the SHU37 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 2-3 | at Shu37 | C. Strong rush for 21 yards to the MILL42, 1ST DOWN SHU, out-of-bounds (J. Satterfield), PENALTY SHU holding (Malik Scott) 10 yards to the SHU48. |
| Shu | 1-20 | at Shu48 | 1st and 10. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu48 | C. Strong pass complete to Jarvis McClam for 5 yards to the MILL47 (Kendall Marks). |
| Shu | 2-5 | at Mill47 | C. Strong pass complete to Jarvis McClam for 27 yards to the MILL20, 1ST DOWN SHU (Kendall Marks). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill20 | C. Strong pass complete to Michael Elardo for 2 yards to the MILL18 (John Jespersen). |
| Shu | 2-8 | at Mill18 | Evan Byrd rush for 7 yards to the MILL11 (Tommy Holloway;John Jespersen). |
| Shu | 3-1 | at Mill11 | Evan Byrd rush for 1 yard to the MILL10, 1ST DOWN SHU (P.J. Santos). |
| Shu | 1-G | at Mill10 | Evan Byrd rush for 1 yard to the MILL9 (Tommy Holloway). |
| Shu | 2-G | at Mill09 | Evan Byrd rush for loss of 1 yard to the MILL10 (Tanner Dean;Kendall Marks). |
| Shu | 3-G | at Mill10 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Malik Scott (Alpha Khan). |
| Shu | 4-G | at Mill10 | Santiago Henao field goal attempt from 25 GOOD, clock 03:09. |
| | | Seton Hill 10, Millersville 7 |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 60 yards, TOP 04:37 |
| | | Santiago Henao kickoff 63 yards to the MILL2, Christian Kemp return 18 yards to the MILL20 (Kurt Adkins). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill20 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 03:04. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill20 | Phil Overton rush for 1 yard to the MILL21 (Alex Attia). |
| Mill | 2-9 | at Mill21 | Sheldon Snell rush for 1 yard to the MILL22 (Alex Attia). |
| Mill | 3-8 | at Mill22 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins. |
| Mill | 4-8 | at Mill22 | Evan Stahl punt 48 yards to the SHU30, Jarvis McClam return 16 yards to the SHU46, out-of-bounds (Paul Somaru). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 2 yards, TOP 01:39 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu46 | SETON HILL drive start at 01:25. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu46 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Norman Darden (Alpha Khan), QB hurry by M. Faughnan. |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Shu46 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Norman Darden. |
| Shu | 3-10 | at Shu46 | Jarvis McClam rush for 8 yards to the MILL46 (Tyler Spangler;Tim Esham). |
| Shu | 4-2 | at Mill46 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Ardell Brown (J. Satterfield). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 8 yards, TOP 00:59 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill46 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 00:26. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill46 | Phil Overton rush for loss of 1 yard to the MILL45 (Alex Attia). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 02:49 |
| | | Seton Hill 10, Millersville 7 |
| Mill | 2-11 | at Mill45 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mill | 2-11 | at Mill45 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Kevin Wiggins for 15 yards to the SHU40, 1ST DOWN MILL (J. Thompson). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu40 | J.J. Paige sacked for loss of 4 yards to the SHU44 (N. Boynton). |
| Mill | 2-14 | at Shu44 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Kevin Wiggins for loss of 1 yard to the SHU45 (Fardan Allen). |
| Mill | 3-15 | at Shu45 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Nii Kotei Nikoi for 45 yards to the SHU0, 1ST DOWN MILL, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:44. |
| | | Evan Stahl kick attempt good. |
| | | Millersville 14, Seton Hill 10 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 54 yards, TOP 02:49 |
| | | Evan Stahl kickoff 56 yards to the SHU9, M. B-Ferguson return 30 yards to the SHU39, out-of-bounds (Evan Stahl). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu39 | SETON HILL drive start at 12:37. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu39 | Khalil Howard rush for 10 yards to the SHU49, 1ST DOWN SHU (Logan Kinser). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu49 | Jarvis McClam rush for 2 yards to the MILL49 (Logan Kinser). |
| Shu | 2-8 | at Mill49 | Jarvis McClam rush for 9 yards to the MILL40, 1ST DOWN SHU (P.J. Santos). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill40 | Khalil Howard rush for 12 yards to the MILL28, 1ST DOWN SHU (Drew Seaburg). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill28 | Khalil Howard rush for 1 yard to the MILL27 (Drew Seaburg;Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 2-9 | at Mill27 | C. Strong pass complete to Norman Darden for 26 yards to the MILL1, 1ST DOWN SHU (J. Satterfield). |
| Shu | 1-G | at Mill01 | C. Strong rush for no gain to the MILL1 (J. Robinson). |
| Shu | 2-G | at Mill01 | Jarvis McClam rush for loss of 1 yard to the MILL2 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 3-G | at Mill02 | Jarvis McClam rush for 2 yards to the MILL0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:15. |
| | | Santiago Henao kick attempt good. |
| | | Seton Hill 17, Millersville 14 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 61 yards, TOP 03:30 |
| | | Santiago Henao kickoff 60 yards to the MILL5, Christian Kemp return 14 yards to the MILL19 (Daquan Glover). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill19 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 09:07. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill19 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Zac Slonac for 11 yards to the MILL30, 1ST DOWN MILL (George Fields;N. Boynton). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill30 | Phil Overton rush for loss of 2 yards to the MILL28 (Alex Attia). |
| Mill | 2-12 | at Mill28 | PENALTY SHU offside 5 yards to the MILL33. |
| Mill | 2-7 | at Mill33 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Phil Overton for 11 yards to the MILL44, 1ST DOWN MILL (Richardo Housen;Travis Day). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill44 | J.J. Paige rush for 2 yards to the MILL46 (Eric Sprys). |
| Mill | 2-8 | at Mill46 | Phil Overton rush for 19 yards to the SHU35, 1ST DOWN MILL (Fardan Allen). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu35 | J.J. Paige rush for 9 yards to the SHU26 (David Gutzmore;Key Smith). |
| Mill | 2-1 | at Shu26 | J.J. Paige rush for no gain to the SHU26 (David Gutzmore). |
| Mill | 3-1 | at Shu26 | Blake Cahill rush for 1 yard to the SHU25 (J. Thompson), PENALTY MILL illegal motion (Blake Cahill) 5 yards to the SHU31, NO PLAY. |
| Mill | 3-6 | at Shu31 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete to Zac Slonac, QB hurry by Tyler Affa. |
| Mill | 4-6 | at Shu31 | J.J. Paige sacked for loss of 4 yards to the SHU35 (David Gutzmore;Alex Attia). |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 46 yards, TOP 05:01 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu35 | SETON HILL drive start at 04:06. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu35 | Jarvis McClam rush for 1 yard to the SHU36, out-of-bounds (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 2-9 | at Shu36 | C. Strong pass complete to Jarvis McClam for 7 yards to the SHU43 (Alpha Khan). |
| Shu | 3-2 | at Shu43 | C. Strong pass complete to Ty George for 4 yards to the SHU47, 1ST DOWN SHU (J. Satterfield). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu47 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Miles Sexton. |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Shu47 | C. Strong rush for 4 yards to the MILL49 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 3-6 | at Mill49 | C. Strong pass complete to Malik Scott for 6 yards to the MILL43, 1ST DOWN SHU (Kendall Marks). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill43 | C. Strong pass complete to Norman Darden for 4 yards to the MILL39, out-of-bounds (J. Satterfield). |
| Shu | 2-6 | at Mill39 | Jarvis McClam rush for 4 yards to the MILL35 (Sean Dugan;John Jespersen). |
| Shu | 3-2 | at Mill35 | Jarvis McClam rush for 2 yards to the MILL33, 1ST DOWN SHU (John Jespersen). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill33 | Timeout Seton Hill, clock 01:17. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill33 | C. Strong pass complete to William Tearney for 8 yards to the MILL25 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 2-2 | at Mill25 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Michael Elardo (Kendall Marks). |
| Shu | 3-2 | at Mill25 | C. Strong pass incomplete, QB hurry by M. Faughnan. |
| Shu | 4-2 | at Mill25 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Logan Carns. |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 40 yards, TOP 03:33 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill25 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 00:33. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill25 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the MILL24. |
| Mill | 2-11 | at Mill24 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:33 |
| | | Seton Hill 17, Millersville 14 |
| Mill | 2-11 | at Mill24 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, MILL ball on MILL35. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:33 |
| | | Evan Stahl kickoff 57 yards to the SHU8, M. B-Ferguson return 33 yards to the SHU41 (John Jespersen). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu41 | SETON HILL drive start at 14:51. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu41 | C. Strong pass complete to Logan Carns for 12 yards to the MILL47, 1ST DOWN SHU, out-of-bounds (Sean Dugan;Drew Seaburg). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill47 | Jarvis McClam rush for 2 yards to the MILL45 (Tim Esham;Logan Kinser). |
| Shu | 2-8 | at Mill45 | C. Strong pass complete to Logan Carns for 5 yards to the MILL40 (J. Satterfield). |
| Shu | 3-3 | at Mill40 | C. Strong pass complete to M. B-Ferguson for 3 yards to the MILL37, 1ST DOWN SHU (J. Satterfield). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill37 | C. Strong pass complete to Ardell Brown for 18 yards to the MILL19, 1ST DOWN SHU (J. Satterfield). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill19 | C. Strong sacked for loss of 6 yards to the MILL25 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 2-16 | at Mill25 | C. Strong pass complete to Ardell Brown for 25 yards to the MILL0, 1ST DOWN SHU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:15. |
| | | Santiago Henao kick attempt good. |
| | | Seton Hill 24, Millersville 14 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 59 yards, TOP 02:36 |
| | | Santiago Henao kickoff 59 yards to the MILL6, out-of-bounds, MILL ball on MILL35. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill35 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 12:15. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill35 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Phil Overton for 1 yard to the MILL36 (Fardan Allen). |
| Mill | 2-9 | at Mill36 | J.J. Paige sacked for loss of 4 yards to the MILL32 (Alex Attia;David Gutzmore). |
| Mill | 3-13 | at Mill32 | J.J. Paige rush for 2 yards to the MILL34 (Tyler Affa;David Gutzmore). |
| Mill | 4-11 | at Mill34 | Evan Stahl punt 47 yards to the SHU19, Jarvis McClam return 24 yards to the SHU43, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 02:10 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu43 | SETON HILL drive start at 10:05. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu43 | Jarvis McClam rush for 7 yards to the 50 yardline (Rob Varner). |
| Shu | 2-3 | at Shu50 | Jarvis McClam rush for no gain to the 50 yardline (Drew Seaburg). |
| Shu | 3-3 | at Shu50 | C. Strong rush for 6 yards to the MILL44, fumble forced by P.J. Santos, fumble by C. Strong recovered by MILL Tyler Spangler at MILL44. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 13 yards, TOP 01:00 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill44 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 09:05. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill44 | J.J. Paige rush for no gain to the MILL44 (David Gutzmore). |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill44 | J.J. Paige rush for 3 yards to the MILL47 (Tim Johnson). |
| Mill | 3-7 | at Mill47 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Kevin Wiggins for 20 yards to the SHU33, 1ST DOWN MILL (Richardo Housen;T. Walton). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu33 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete to Christian Kemp. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Shu33 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete. |
| Mill | 3-10 | at Shu33 | J.J. Paige rush for 5 yards to the SHU28 (David Gutzmore), PENALTY SHU holding declined, PENALTY SHU personal foul (David Gutzmore) 12 yards to the SHU16, 1ST DOWN MILL. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu16 | 1st and 10. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu16 | Phil Overton pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins (Fardan Allen). |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Shu16 | Phil Overton rush for 16 yards to the SHU0, 1ST DOWN MILL, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:28. |
| | | Evan Stahl kick attempt good. |
| | | Seton Hill 24, Millersville 21 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 56 yards, TOP 02:43 |
| | | Evan Stahl kickoff 61 yards to the SHU4, Malik Scott return 13 yards to the SHU17 (Paul Somaru). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu17 | SETON HILL drive start at 06:22. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu17 | C. Strong pass complete to Jarvis McClam for 83 yards to the MILL0, 1ST DOWN SHU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:08. |
| | | Santiago Henao kick attempt good, PENALTY MILL offside declined. |
| | | Seton Hill 31, Millersville 21 |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 83 yards, TOP 00:22 |
| | | Santiago Henao kickoff 59 yards to the MILL6, Christian Kemp return 26 yards to the MILL32 (Dexter Williams). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill32 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 06:00. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill32 | Christian Kemp rush for 6 yards to the MILL38 (Fardan Allen). |
| Mill | 2-4 | at Mill38 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete, QB hurry by Eric Sprys, PENALTY MILL IS 5 yards to the MILL33, NO PLAY. |
| Mill | 2-9 | at Mill33 | Timeout Millersville, clock 05:09. |
| Mill | 2-9 | at Mill33 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Kevin Wiggins for 6 yards to the MILL39, out-of-bounds (T. Walton). |
| Mill | 3-3 | at Mill39 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Tyler Zilen for 12 yards to the SHU49, 1ST DOWN MILL (David Gutzmore). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu49 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Tyler Zilen for 8 yards to the SHU41 (David Gutzmore;T. Walton). |
| Mill | 2-2 | at Shu41 | Phil Overton rush for 9 yards to the SHU32, 1ST DOWN MILL (Tim Johnson). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu32 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete to Blake Cahill (Fardan Allen). |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Shu32 | Phil Overton rush for 4 yards to the SHU28 (Jeremy Perkins). |
| Mill | 3-6 | at Shu28 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete to Phil Overton. |
| Mill | 4-6 | at Shu28 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Zac Slonac for 7 yards to the SHU21, 1ST DOWN MILL (Richardo Housen;Dexter Williams). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu21 | Phil Overton rush for 2 yards to the SHU19 (Alex Attia;Tyler Affa). |
| Mill | 2-8 | at Shu19 | Phil Overton rush for 9 yards to the SHU10, 1ST DOWN MILL (Tim Johnson). |
| Mill | 1-G | at Shu10 | Phil Overton rush for 3 yards to the SHU7 (Tim Johnson). |
| Mill | 2-G | at Shu07 | J.J. Paige sacked for loss of 8 yards to the SHU15 (Tyler Affa). |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 53 yards, TOP 06:30 |
| | | Seton Hill 31, Millersville 21 |
| Mill | 3-G | at Shu15 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mill | 3-G | at Shu15 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins. |
| Mill | 4-G | at Shu15 | Evan Stahl field goal attempt from 32 GOOD, clock 14:48. |
| | | Seton Hill 31, Millersville 24 |
| | | Drive: 15 plays, 53 yards, TOP 06:30 |
| | | Evan Stahl kickoff 52 yards to the SHU13, Malik Scott return 13 yards to the SHU26 (N. Kilpatrick). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu26 | SETON HILL drive start at 14:30. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu26 | C. Strong pass complete to Logan Carns for 3 yards to the SHU29 (P.J. Santos). |
| Shu | 2-7 | at Shu29 | Jarvis McClam rush for 10 yards to the SHU39, 1ST DOWN SHU (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu39 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Logan Carns. |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Shu39 | Jarvis McClam rush for 3 yards to the SHU42 (Rob Varner), PENALTY SHU holding (Logan Carns) 15 yards to the SHU27. |
| Shu | 2-22 | at Shu27 | 2nd and 22. |
| Shu | 2-22 | at Shu27 | C. Strong pass complete to Jarvis McClam for 12 yards to the SHU39 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 3-10 | at Shu39 | C. Strong pass complete to Jarvis McClam for 7 yards to the SHU46 (J. Satterfield). |
| Shu | 4-3 | at Shu46 | William Hodge punt 36 yards to the MILL18, fair catch by Phil Overton. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 20 yards, TOP 02:44 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill18 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 11:46. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill18 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete, QB hurry by Key Smith, PENALTY MILL intentional grounding 8 yards to the MILL10. |
| Mill | 2-18 | at Mill10 | 2nd and 18. |
| Mill | 2-18 | at Mill10 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete to Phil Overton. |
| Mill | 3-18 | at Mill10 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Phil Overton for 6 yards to the MILL16 (D. Wariboko;T. Best-Savage). |
| Mill | 4-12 | at Mill16 | Evan Stahl punt 42 yards to the SHU42, Ardell Brown return 30 yards to the MILL28, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 01:22 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill28 | SETON HILL drive start at 10:24. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill28 | Jarvis McClam rush for 7 yards to the MILL21 (Alpha Khan). |
| Shu | 2-3 | at Mill21 | Evan Byrd rush for 19 yards to the MILL2, 1ST DOWN SHU (Kendall Marks). |
| Shu | 1-G | at Mill02 | Khalil Howard rush for 2 yards to the MILL0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:43. |
| | | Santiago Henao kick attempt good. |
| | | Seton Hill 38, Millersville 24 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 28 yards, TOP 00:41 |
| | | Santiago Henao kickoff 59 yards to the MILL6, out-of-bounds, MILL ball on MILL35. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill35 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 09:43. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill35 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Christian Kemp for 29 yards to the SHU36, 1ST DOWN MILL, out-of-bounds (Dexter Williams;Travis Day). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu36 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins, dropped pass. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Shu36 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins, PENALTY SHU holding 10 yards to the SHU26, 1ST DOWN MILL, NO PLAY. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu26 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Christian Kemp for 21 yards to the SHU5, fumble by Christian Kemp recovered by SHU Tim Johnson at SHU5. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 60 yards, TOP 00:44 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu05 | SETON HILL drive start at 08:59. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu05 | Khalil Howard rush for 5 yards to the SHU10 (Tommy Holloway;Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 2-5 | at Shu10 | Khalil Howard rush for 3 yards to the SHU13 (M. Faughnan;Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 3-2 | at Shu13 | Evan Byrd rush for 5 yards to the SHU18, 1ST DOWN SHU (Kendall Marks). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu18 | Evan Byrd rush for 3 yards to the SHU21 (M. Fitzpatrick;M. Faughnan). |
| Shu | 2-7 | at Shu21 | Ardell Brown rush for loss of 11 yards to the SHU10 (J. Robinson). |
| Shu | 3-18 | at Shu10 | PENALTY SHU false start 5 yards to the SHU5. |
| Shu | 3-23 | at Shu05 | C. Strong pass incomplete. |
| Shu | 4-23 | at Shu05 | William Hodge punt 46 yards to the MILL49, fair catch by Phil Overton. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 0 yards, TOP 04:01 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill49 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 04:58. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill49 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Phil Overton for 22 yards to the SHU29, 1ST DOWN MILL (Tyler Affa). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu29 | Ryan O'Donnell rush for loss of 1 yard to the SHU30, fumble by Ryan O'Donnell recovered by SHU Tyler Affa at SHU32. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 19 yards, TOP 00:30 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu32 | SETON HILL drive start at 04:28. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu32 | Evan Byrd rush for 4 yards to the SHU36 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 2-6 | at Shu36 | C. Strong pass complete to Ty George for 4 yards to the SHU40 (Kendall Marks). |
| Shu | 3-2 | at Shu40 | Evan Byrd rush for 20 yards to the MILL40, 1ST DOWN SHU (J. Satterfield). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill40 | Khalil Howard rush for 4 yards to the MILL36 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 2-6 | at Mill36 | Khalil Howard rush for 7 yards to the MILL29, 1ST DOWN SHU (P.J. Santos;Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill29 | Khalil Howard rush for 7 yards to the MILL22 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 2-3 | at Mill22 | Timeout Millersville, clock 01:27. |
| Shu | 2-3 | at Mill22 | Khalil Howard rush for loss of 4 yards to the MILL26 (Sean Dugan;Tommy Holloway). |
| Shu | 3-7 | at Mill26 | Timeout Millersville, clock 01:20. |
| Shu | 3-7 | at Mill26 | C. Strong pass incomplete to M. B-Ferguson (J. Satterfield). |
| Shu | 4-7 | at Mill26 | Timeout Seton Hill, clock 01:11. |
| Shu | 4-7 | at Mill26 | PENALTY SHU false start (AJ Lassiter) 5 yards to the MILL31. |
| Shu | 4-12 | at Mill31 | C. Strong pass complete to Jarvis McClam for 8 yards to the MILL23. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 45 yards, TOP 03:22 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill23 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 01:06. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill23 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Blake Cahill for 6 yards to the MILL29 (N. Boynton). |
| Mill | 2-4 | at Mill29 | J.J. Paige pass complete to Christian Kemp for 22 yards to the SHU49, 1ST DOWN MILL, out-of-bounds. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu49 | J.J. Paige rush for 2 yards to the SHU47 (N. Boynton). |
| Mill | 2-8 | at Shu47 | J.J. Paige pass incomplete. |
| Mill | 3-8 | at Shu47 | J.J. Paige sacked for loss of 10 yards to the MILL43 (K. Petit-Frere). |
| Mill | 4-18 | at Mill43 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 20 yards, TOP 01:06 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Seton Hill 38, Millersville 24 |