| | | Seton Hill wins the toss and will receive. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill35 | MILL ball on MILL35. |
| | | Tyler Reiman kickoff 60 yards to the SHU5, C. Sweeting return 9 yards to the SHU14 (D. Niedbalski). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu14 | C. Strong pass complete to Kurt Adkins for 2 yards to the SHU16 (Cameron Boykin;Marcel Mingo), PENALTY SHU holding 8 yards to the SHU8. |
| Shu | 1-16 | at Shu08 | 1st and 16. |
| Shu | 1-16 | at Shu08 | C. Strong pass complete to Ty George for 5 yards to the SHU13 (J. Satterfield). |
| Shu | 2-11 | at Shu13 | C. Strong pass complete to M. Williams for 4 yards to the SHU17 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 3-7 | at Shu17 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Kurt Adkins, dropped pass. |
| Shu | 4-7 | at Shu17 | Matt Stewart punt 31 yards to the SHU48, Jhet Janis return 7 yards to the SHU41 (M. Valentino). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 3 yards, TOP 01:18 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu41 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 13:42. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu41 | Collin Shank pass complete to Kevin Wiggins for 23 yards to the SHU18, 1ST DOWN MILL (Noah Davis). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu18 | Collin Shank rush for 7 yards to the SHU11 (Cole Shuker). |
| Mill | 2-3 | at Shu11 | TEAM rush for loss of 5 yards to the SHU16, fumble by TEAM recovered by SHU J. Lissade at SHU16, PENALTY SHU offside 5 yards to the SHU6, 1ST DOWN MILL, NO PLAY. |
| Mill | 1-G | at Shu06 | PENALTY MILL false start 5 yards to the SHU11. |
| Mill | 1-G | at Shu11 | Collin Shank rush for 1 yard to the SHU10 (J. Emberton-Gai). |
| Mill | 2-G | at Shu10 | Collin Shank sacked for loss of 5 yards to the SHU15 (Cole Shuker). |
| Mill | 3-G | at Shu15 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Xavier Jenkins. |
| Mill | 4-G | at Shu15 | TEAM rush for loss of 9 yards to the SHU24, fumble by TEAM recovered by MILL Collin Shank at SHU24 (J. Emberton-Gai). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 17 yards, TOP 03:00 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu24 | SETON HILL drive start at 10:42. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu24 | Evan Byrd rush for 2 yards to the SHU26 (Trejon Dinkins;Cameron Boykin). |
| Shu | 2-8 | at Shu26 | C. Strong pass complete to T. Knuettel for 8 yards to the SHU34, 1ST DOWN SHU (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu34 | C. Sweeting rush for 1 yard to the SHU35 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 2-9 | at Shu35 | PENALTY SHU false start 5 yards to the SHU30. |
| Shu | 2-14 | at Shu30 | C. Strong pass incomplete to M. Williams, PENALTY MILL holding 10 yards to the SHU40, 1ST DOWN SHU, NO PLAY. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu40 | Khalil Owens rush for 6 yards to the SHU46 (Sean Dugan;Trejon Dinkins). |
| Shu | 2-4 | at Shu46 | C. Strong pass complete to M. Williams for 2 yards to the SHU48 (Kendle Pitts). |
| Shu | 3-2 | at Shu48 | C. Sweeting rush for 2 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN SHU (Cameron Boykin;M. Faughnan). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu50 | Khalil Owens rush for 2 yards to the MILL48 (Sean Dugan;Tommy Halloway). |
| Shu | 2-8 | at Mill48 | C. Strong pass complete to Evan Byrd for 6 yards to the MILL42 (Jhet Janis;Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 3-2 | at Mill42 | Evan Byrd rush for 3 yards to the MILL39, 1ST DOWN SHU (Sean Dugan;M. Faughnan). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill39 | C. Strong pass complete to T. Knuettel for 20 yards to the MILL19, 1ST DOWN SHU (Cameron Boykin). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill19 | C. Sweeting rush for 5 yards to the MILL14 (J. Satterfield). |
| Shu | 2-5 | at Mill14 | C. Strong pass complete to Brian Ingram for 13 yards to the MILL1, 1ST DOWN SHU (Drew Seaburg). |
| Shu | 1-G | at Mill01 | Evan Byrd rush for 1 yard to the MILL0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:00. |
| | | Santiago Henao kick attempt good. |
| | | Seton Hill 7, Millersville 0 |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 76 yards, TOP 04:42 |
| | | Santiago Henao kickoff 55 yards to the MILL10, out-of-bounds, MILL ball on MILL35. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill35 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 06:00. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill35 | Collin Shank pass complete to Xavier Jenkins for 18 yards to the SHU47, 1ST DOWN MILL (Fardan Allen). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu47 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Shu47 | Collin Shank pass complete to Kobe Miranda for 14 yards to the SHU33, 1ST DOWN MILL (Noah Davis). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu33 | Kobe Miranda rush for 5 yards to the SHU28 (Noah Davis), PENALTY MILL illegal block 15 yards to the SHU43. |
| Mill | 1-20 | at Shu43 | 1st and 20. |
| Mill | 1-20 | at Shu43 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins. |
| Mill | 2-20 | at Shu43 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Jaelyn Gaither, PENALTY SHU roughing passer 15 yards to the SHU28, 1ST DOWN MILL, NO PLAY. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu28 | Kobe Miranda rush for 23 yards to the SHU5, 1ST DOWN MILL (J. Lissade;Malik Scott). |
| Mill | 1-G | at Shu05 | Kobe Miranda rush for 2 yards to the SHU3 (J. Emberton-Gai;Jeremy Perkins), PENALTY SHU illegal participation 2 yards to the SHU3, NO PLAY. |
| Mill | 1-G | at Shu03 | Kobe Miranda rush for no gain to the SHU3 (J. Emberton-Gai;J. Thompson). |
| Mill | 2-G | at Shu03 | Kobe Miranda rush for 1 yard to the SHU2 (J. Emberton-Gai;Cole Shuker). |
| Mill | 3-G | at Shu02 | Timeout Millersville, clock 02:47. |
| Mill | 3-G | at Shu02 | Kobe Miranda rush for no gain to the SHU2 (Tyler Affa;J. Emberton-Gai). |
| Mill | 4-G | at Shu02 | Timeout Millersville, clock 01:58. |
| Mill | 4-G | at Shu02 | Collin Shank rush for 2 yards to the SHU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:55. |
| | | Joey Farley kick attempt good, PENALTY SHU illegal participation declined. |
| | | Millersville 7, Seton Hill 7 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 65 yards, TOP 04:10 |
| | | Tyler Reiman kickoff 53 yards to the SHU12, C. Sweeting return 17 yards to the SHU29 (Nate Hiligh;D. Niedbalski). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu29 | SETON HILL drive start at 01:50. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu29 | PENALTY SHU false start 5 yards to the SHU24. |
| Shu | 1-15 | at Shu24 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Kurt Adkins. |
| Shu | 2-15 | at Shu24 | C. Strong pass complete to Michael Elardo for 11 yards to the SHU35 (B. Sherman), PENALTY SHU holding 10 yards to the SHU14, NO PLAY. |
| Shu | 2-25 | at Shu14 | C. Strong pass complete to Kurt Adkins for 5 yards to the SHU19 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 3-20 | at Shu19 | C. Strong pass complete to Michael Elardo for 27 yards to the SHU46, 1ST DOWN SHU (Colin Suhr;Kendle Pitts). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu46 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Kurt Adkins. |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Shu46 | C. Strong pass complete to Michael Elardo for 7 yards to the MILL47 (Kendle Pitts). |
| Shu | 3-3 | at Mill47 | C. Strong rush for loss of 1 yard to the MILL48, fumble forced by Tykeem Dixon, fumble by C. Strong recovered by SHU C. Strong at MILL48. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 23 yards, TOP 01:55 |
| | | Millersville 7, Seton Hill 7 |
| Shu | 4-4 | at Mill48 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Shu | 4-4 | at Mill48 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Ty George, QB hurry by Sean Dugan. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 23 yards, TOP 01:55 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill48 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 14:55. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill48 | Collin Shank pass complete to Nii Kotei Nikoi for 23 yards to the SHU29, 1ST DOWN MILL (J. Emberton-Gai). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu29 | Collin Shank pass complete to Tyrone Gibson for 20 yards to the SHU9, 1ST DOWN MILL (Fardan Allen). |
| Mill | 1-G | at Shu09 | Collin Shank pass complete to D. Niedbalski for 9 yards to the SHU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 13:42. |
| | | Joey Farley kick attempt good. |
| | | Millersville 14, Seton Hill 7 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 52 yards, TOP 01:20 |
| | | Tyler Reiman kickoff 48 yards to the SHU17, C. Sweeting return 14 yards to the SHU31 (Jhet Janis). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu31 | SETON HILL drive start at 13:35. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu31 | C. Sweeting rush for 52 yards to the MILL17, 1ST DOWN SHU (Jaleel Robinson). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill17 | Evan Byrd rush for no gain to the MILL17 (Drew Seaburg). |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Mill17 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Khalil Owens. |
| Shu | 3-10 | at Mill17 | C. Strong pass complete to M. Williams for 17 yards to the MILL0, 1ST DOWN SHU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:14. |
| | | Santiago Henao kick attempt good. |
| | | Millersville 14, Seton Hill 14 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 69 yards, TOP 01:21 |
| | | Santiago Henao kickoff 63 yards to the MILL2, downed. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill02 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 12:14. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill02 | Phil Overton rush for 2 yards to the MILL4 (Cole Shuker;J. Thompson). |
| Mill | 2-8 | at Mill04 | Phil Overton rush for 1 yard to the MILL5 (J. Thompson;Cole Shuker). |
| Mill | 3-7 | at Mill05 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Tyrone Gibson. |
| Mill | 4-7 | at Mill05 | Tyler Reiman punt 23 yards to the MILL28, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 01:23 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill28 | SETON HILL drive start at 10:51. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill28 | Khalil Owens rush for 4 yards to the MILL24 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 2-6 | at Mill24 | C. Strong pass complete to Ty George for 21 yards to the MILL3, 1ST DOWN SHU, out-of-bounds (Jhet Janis). |
| Shu | 1-G | at Mill03 | Khalil Owens rush for 2 yards to the MILL1 (Drew Seaburg;Trejon Dinkins). |
| Shu | 2-G | at Mill01 | M. Valentino rush for 1 yard to the MILL0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:15. |
| | | Santiago Henao kick attempt good. |
| | | Seton Hill 21, Millersville 14 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 28 yards, TOP 01:36 |
| | | Santiago Henao kickoff 65 yards to the MILL0, touchback. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill25 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 09:15. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill25 | Kevin Wiggins rush for 5 yards to the MILL30 (J. Culpepper). |
| Mill | 2-5 | at Mill30 | Collin Shank pass complete to Xavier Jenkins for 6 yards to the MILL36, 1ST DOWN MILL (Fardan Allen). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill36 | Collin Shank pass complete to Tyrone Gibson for 24 yards to the SHU40, 1ST DOWN MILL (Fardan Allen). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu40 | Tyrone Gibson rush for 4 yards to the SHU36 (Jeremy Perkins). |
| Mill | 2-6 | at Shu36 | Collin Shank rush for 3 yards to the SHU33 (Tyler Affa). |
| Mill | 3-3 | at Shu33 | Kobe Miranda rush for 11 yards to the SHU22, 1ST DOWN MILL (Noah Davis;Cole Shuker). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu22 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins, PENALTY SHU pass interference 15 yards to the SHU7, 1ST DOWN MILL, NO PLAY. |
| Mill | 1-G | at Shu07 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Tyler Zilen. |
| Mill | 2-G | at Shu07 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins (Noah Davis). |
| Mill | 3-G | at Shu07 | Collin Shank pass complete to Pearson Hinkle for 6 yards to the SHU1 (J. Emberton-Gai;T. Best-Savage). |
| Mill | 4-G | at Shu01 | Phil Overton rush for no gain to the SHU1 (J. Thompson;Keelyn Brown). |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 74 yards, TOP 03:38 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu01 | SETON HILL drive start at 05:37. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu01 | C. Sweeting rush for 1 yard to the SHU2 (Marcel Mingo;Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 2-9 | at Shu02 | Evan Byrd rush for 1 yard to the SHU3 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 3-8 | at Shu03 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Ty George. |
| Shu | 4-8 | at Shu03 | Matt Stewart punt 35 yards to the SHU38, Jhet Janis return 4 yards to the SHU34 (J. Emberton-Gai), PENALTY MILL illegal block 10 yards to the SHU44, 1st and 10, MILL ball on SHU44. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 2 yards, TOP 01:38 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu44 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 03:59. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu44 | Collin Shank pass complete to Kobe Miranda for 23 yards to the SHU21, 1ST DOWN MILL (Fardan Allen). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu21 | PENALTY MILL personal foul 15 yards to the SHU36. |
| Mill | 1-25 | at Shu36 | 1st and 10. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu36 | Collin Shank pass complete to Phil Overton for 24 yards to the SHU12, 1ST DOWN MILL (J. Emberton-Gai). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu12 | Kobe Miranda rush for 2 yards to the SHU10 (Eric Sprys). |
| Mill | 2-8 | at Shu10 | Kobe Miranda rush for 6 yards to the SHU4 (Jeremy Perkins;J. Emberton-Gai). |
| Mill | 3-2 | at Shu04 | Collin Shank pass complete to Kevin Wiggins for 4 yards to the SHU0, 1ST DOWN MILL, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:03. |
| | | Joey Farley kick attempt good. |
| | | Millersville 21, Seton Hill 21 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 44 yards, TOP 01:56 |
| | | Tyler Reiman kickoff 43 yards to the SHU22, fair catch by Malik Scott. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu22 | SETON HILL drive start at 02:03. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu22 | C. Sweeting rush for 7 yards to the SHU29 (Trejon Dinkins). |
| Shu | 2-3 | at Shu29 | C. Sweeting rush for 2 yards to the SHU31 (Tommy Halloway). |
| Shu | 3-1 | at Shu31 | Evan Byrd rush for 1 yard to the SHU32, 1ST DOWN SHU (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu32 | C. Strong pass incomplete to John Makell IV. |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Shu32 | C. Strong pass complete to Brian Ingram for 44 yards to the MILL24, 1ST DOWN SHU (Kendle Pitts). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill24 | C. Strong pass complete to T. Knuettel for no gain to the MILL24 (Marcel Mingo). |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Mill24 | Timeout Seton Hill, clock 00:34. |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Mill24 | C. Strong pass incomplete to C. Sweeting, QB hurry by Nate Hiligh. |
| Shu | 3-10 | at Mill24 | C. Strong pass incomplete to T. Knuettel (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 4-10 | at Mill24 | Santiago Henao field goal attempt from 41 GOOD, clock 00:22. |
| | | Seton Hill 24, Millersville 21 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 54 yards, TOP 01:48 |
| | | Santiago Henao kickoff 59 yards to the MILL6, Kendle Pitts return 16 yards to the MILL22 (Logan Wiland), PENALTY MILL holding 10 yards to the MILL12, 1st and 10, MILL ball on MILL12. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill12 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 00:15. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill12 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the MILL11. |
| Mill | 2-11 | at Mill11 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:15 |
| | | Seton Hill 24, Millersville 21 |
| Mill | 2-11 | at Mill11 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, SHU ball on SHU35. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:15 |
| | | Santiago Henao kickoff 22 yards to the MILL43, on-side kick, recovered by MILL Jhet Janis on MILL43, PENALTY SHU offside 5 yards to the MILL48, 1st and 10, MILL ball on MILL48. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill48 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 14:59. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill48 | Collin Shank pass complete to Nii Kotei Nikoi for 27 yards to the SHU25, 1ST DOWN MILL (T. Best-Savage). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu25 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins (J. Lissade). |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Shu25 | Phil Overton rush for 4 yards to the SHU21 (J. Thompson). |
| Mill | 3-6 | at Shu21 | Phil Overton rush for 4 yards to the SHU17 (J. Emberton-Gai;J. Thompson). |
| Mill | 4-2 | at Shu17 | Timeout Seton Hill, clock 13:25. |
| Mill | 4-2 | at Shu17 | Collin Shank rush for 3 yards to the SHU14, 1ST DOWN MILL (J. Emberton-Gai). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu14 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Shu14 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins. |
| Mill | 3-10 | at Shu14 | Collin Shank pass complete to Tyrone Gibson for 1 yard to the SHU13 (J. Emberton-Gai). |
| Mill | 4-9 | at Shu13 | Joey Farley field goal attempt from 30 GOOD, clock 12:09. |
| | | Millersville 24, Seton Hill 24 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 39 yards, TOP 02:56 |
| | | Tyler Reiman kickoff 50 yards to the SHU15, C. Sweeting return 20 yards to the SHU35 (J. Satterfield). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu35 | SETON HILL drive start at 12:03. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu35 | C. Strong pass incomplete to M. Williams (Marcel Mingo). |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Shu35 | C. Strong pass complete to M. Williams for 10 yards to the SHU45, 1ST DOWN SHU (Sean Dugan;Jhet Janis). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu45 | C. Strong pass incomplete to M. Williams, dropped pass. |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Shu45 | C. Strong pass complete to John Makell IV for 7 yards to the MILL48 (Trejon Dinkins). |
| Shu | 3-3 | at Mill48 | C. Sweeting rush for 5 yards to the MILL43, 1ST DOWN SHU (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill43 | Khalil Owens rush for 16 yards to the MILL27, 1ST DOWN SHU (Trejon Dinkins). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill27 | Khalil Owens rush for 8 yards to the MILL19 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 2-2 | at Mill19 | M. Valentino rush for 2 yards to the MILL17, 1ST DOWN SHU (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill17 | C. Strong pass incomplete to M. Valentino. |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Mill17 | C. Strong pass incomplete to John Makell IV. |
| Shu | 3-10 | at Mill17 | C. Strong pass complete to C. Sweeting for 17 yards to the MILL0, 1ST DOWN SHU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:21. |
| | | Santiago Henao kick attempt good. |
| | | Seton Hill 31, Millersville 24 |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 65 yards, TOP 02:46 |
| | | Santiago Henao kickoff 55 yards to the MILL10, Kendle Pitts return 14 yards to the MILL24 (Logan Wiland). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill24 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 09:17. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill24 | Collin Shank pass complete to Kevin Wiggins for 10 yards to the MILL34, 1ST DOWN MILL (Sam Pagella). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill34 | Tyrone Gibson rush for loss of 5 yards to the MILL29 (Eric Sprys). |
| Mill | 2-15 | at Mill29 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins (Fardan Allen). |
| Mill | 3-15 | at Mill29 | Collin Shank rush for 2 yards to the MILL31 (Fardan Allen), PENALTY SHU holding 10 yards to the MILL41. |
| Mill | 3-3 | at Mill41 | 3rd and 3. |
| Mill | 3-3 | at Mill41 | Tyrone Gibson rush for 18 yards to the SHU41, 1ST DOWN MILL (Noah Davis). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu41 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Tyler Zilen. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Shu41 | Tyrone Gibson rush for 14 yards to the SHU27, 1ST DOWN MILL (Fardan Allen). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu27 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Nii Kotei Nikoi (T. Best-Savage). |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Shu27 | Collin Shank pass complete to Phil Overton for 27 yards to the SHU0, 1ST DOWN MILL, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:46. |
| | | Joey Farley kick attempt good. |
| | | Millersville 31, Seton Hill 31 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 76 yards, TOP 02:38 |
| | | Tyler Reiman kickoff 52 yards to the SHU13, C. Sweeting return 29 yards to the SHU42 (Colin Suhr). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu42 | SETON HILL drive start at 06:39. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu42 | Michael Elardo rush for 4 yards to the SHU46 (Logan Kinser). |
| Shu | 2-6 | at Shu46 | C. Strong pass intercepted by Trejon Dinkins at the MILL44, Trejon Dinkins return 0 yards to the MILL44. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 4 yards, TOP 00:42 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill44 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 05:57. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill44 | Kobe Miranda rush for 2 yards to the MILL46 (J. Emberton-Gai;J. Thompson). |
| Mill | 2-8 | at Mill46 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Xavier Jenkins (Fardan Allen). |
| Mill | 3-8 | at Mill46 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Nii Kotei Nikoi. |
| Mill | 4-8 | at Mill46 | Tyler Reiman punt 42 yards to the SHU12, fair catch by C. Sweeting. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 2 yards, TOP 00:54 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu12 | SETON HILL drive start at 05:03. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu12 | C. Sweeting rush for no gain to the SHU12 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Shu12 | C. Strong pass complete to Michael Elardo for 32 yards to the SHU44, 1ST DOWN SHU (Jaleel Robinson), PENALTY MILL face mask 15 yards to the MILL41, 1ST DOWN SHU. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill41 | 1st and 10. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill41 | Khalil Owens rush for 5 yards to the MILL36 (Sheldon Snell;Cameron Boykin). |
| Shu | 2-5 | at Mill36 | Khalil Owens rush for no gain to the MILL36 (J. Satterfield;Sean Dugan), PENALTY MILL illegal use of hands 10 yards to the MILL26, 1ST DOWN SHU. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill26 | 1st and 10. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill26 | C. Sweeting rush for 3 yards to the MILL23 (Sheldon Snell). |
| Shu | 2-7 | at Mill23 | C. Strong pass complete to Michael Elardo for 23 yards to the MILL0, 1ST DOWN SHU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:54. |
| | | Santiago Henao kick attempt good. |
| | | Seton Hill 38, Millersville 31 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 88 yards, TOP 02:16 |
| | | Santiago Henao kickoff 45 yards to the MILL20, Kendle Pitts return 11 yards to the MILL31 (Teegan Hahn;M. Valentino). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill31 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 02:47. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill31 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Xavier Jenkins. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill31 | Collin Shank pass complete to Kevin Wiggins for 14 yards to the MILL45, 1ST DOWN MILL (T. Best-Savage). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill45 | Tyrone Gibson rush for no gain to the MILL45 (M. Nicholas), PENALTY MILL holding 10 yards to the MILL35, NO PLAY. |
| Mill | 1-20 | at Mill35 | Collin Shank pass complete to Xavier Jenkins for 12 yards to the MILL47 (Kyle Murphy). |
| Mill | 2-8 | at Mill47 | Collin Shank pass complete to Nii Kotei Nikoi for 20 yards to the SHU33, 1ST DOWN MILL (Kyle Murphy). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu33 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Shu33 | Collin Shank pass complete to Xavier Jenkins for 11 yards to the SHU22, 1ST DOWN MILL (T. Best-Savage). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu22 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins (Kyle Murphy), PENALTY SHU roughing passer 11 yards to the SHU11, 1ST DOWN MILL, NO PLAY. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu11 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Tyrone Gibson, PENALTY SHU roughing passer 5 yards to the SHU6, 1ST DOWN MILL, NO PLAY. |
| Mill | 1-G | at Shu06 | Kobe Miranda rush for no gain to the SHU6 (J. Thompson). |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 63 yards, TOP 02:54 |
| | | Seton Hill 38, Millersville 31 |
| Mill | 2-G | at Shu06 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mill | 2-G | at Shu06 | Collin Shank pass intercepted by T. Best-Savage at the SHU0, T. Best-Savage return 0 yards to the SHU0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 63 yards, TOP 02:54 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu20 | SETON HILL drive start at 14:53. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu20 | C. Sweeting rush for 4 yards to the SHU24 (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 2-6 | at Shu24 | C. Strong pass complete to T. Knuettel for 6 yards to the SHU30 (Kendle Pitts), PENALTY SHU holding 10 yards to the SHU20. |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Shu20 | 2nd and 10. |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Shu20 | C. Strong pass incomplete to M. Williams. |
| Shu | 3-10 | at Shu20 | C. Strong pass complete to M. Williams for 24 yards to the SHU44, 1ST DOWN SHU (Marcel Mingo). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu44 | C. Strong pass complete to T. Knuettel for 53 yards to the MILL3 (Marcel Mingo), PENALTY SHU holding 10 yards to the SHU34, NO PLAY. |
| Shu | 1-20 | at Shu34 | C. Sweeting rush for 2 yards to the SHU36 (Marcel Mingo). |
| Shu | 2-18 | at Shu36 | C. Strong pass complete to Michael Elardo for 17 yards to the MILL47 (Trejon Dinkins). |
| Shu | 3-1 | at Mill47 | C. Sweeting rush for 5 yards to the MILL42, 1ST DOWN SHU (Sean Dugan). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill42 | C. Strong pass complete to John Makell IV for 12 yards to the MILL30, 1ST DOWN SHU (Colin Suhr). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill30 | C. Strong pass complete to John Makell IV for 16 yards to the MILL14, 1ST DOWN SHU (Trejon Dinkins). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill14 | C. Strong pass complete to Uriah Golding for loss of 5 yards to the MILL19 (Tykeem Dixon). |
| Shu | 2-15 | at Mill19 | C. Strong pass intercepted by Tanner Dean at the MILL23, Tanner Dean return 10 yards to the MILL33 (Khalil Owens). |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 61 yards, TOP 04:08 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill33 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 10:45. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill33 | Collin Shank pass complete to Tyler Zilen for 6 yards to the MILL39 (Brent Leone). |
| Mill | 2-4 | at Mill39 | Phil Overton rush for 4 yards to the MILL43, 1ST DOWN MILL (J. Culpepper). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill43 | Phil Overton rush for 12 yards to the SHU45, 1ST DOWN MILL (K. Petit-Frere). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu45 | Phil Overton rush for loss of 3 yards to the SHU48 (Eric Sprys). |
| Mill | 2-13 | at Shu48 | Collin Shank pass complete to Nii Kotei Nikoi for 7 yards to the SHU41 (Cole Shuker). |
| Mill | 3-6 | at Shu41 | Collin Shank pass complete to Phil Overton for 20 yards to the SHU21, 1ST DOWN MILL (J. Emberton-Gai;Noah Davis). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu21 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Xavier Jenkins. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Shu21 | Collin Shank pass complete to Kevin Wiggins for 8 yards to the SHU13 (T. Best-Savage). |
| Mill | 3-2 | at Shu13 | Phil Overton rush for 4 yards to the SHU9, 1ST DOWN MILL (Dennis Law, Jr). |
| Mill | 1-G | at Shu09 | Timeout Seton Hill, clock 07:28. |
| Mill | 1-G | at Shu09 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Phil Overton. |
| Mill | 2-G | at Shu09 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Xavier Jenkins. |
| Mill | 3-G | at Shu09 | Collin Shank pass incomplete, PENALTY SHU pass interference 7 yards to the SHU2, 1ST DOWN MILL, NO PLAY. |
| Mill | 1-G | at Shu02 | Kobe Miranda rush for no gain to the SHU2 (Cole Shuker;Tyler Affa). |
| Mill | 2-G | at Shu02 | Kobe Miranda rush for 1 yard to the SHU1 (Cole Shuker;Sam Pagella). |
| Mill | 3-G | at Shu01 | Collin Shank rush for 1 yard to the SHU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:10. |
| | | Joey Farley kick attempt good. |
| | | Millersville 38, Seton Hill 38 |
| | | Drive: 14 plays, 67 yards, TOP 04:41 |
| | | Tyler Reiman kickoff 37 yards to the SHU28, Logan Wiland return 8 yards to the SHU36 (D. Niedbalski). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu36 | SETON HILL drive start at 06:04. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu36 | C. Sweeting rush for 2 yards to the SHU38 (J. Satterfield). |
| Shu | 2-8 | at Shu38 | C. Strong pass complete to C. Sweeting for no gain to the SHU38 (Colin Suhr). |
| Shu | 3-8 | at Shu38 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Ty George. |
| Shu | 4-8 | at Shu38 | Matt Stewart punt 56 yards to the MILL6, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 2 yards, TOP 01:24 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill06 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 04:40. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill06 | Kevin Wiggins rush for loss of 1 yard to the MILL5 (Tyler Affa;Malik Scott). |
| Mill | 2-11 | at Mill05 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Kevin Wiggins. |
| Mill | 3-11 | at Mill05 | PENALTY MILL sideline interference 2 yards to the MILL3. |
| Mill | 3-13 | at Mill03 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Xavier Jenkins (Fardan Allen). |
| Mill | 4-13 | at Mill03 | Tyler Reiman punt 47 yards to the 50 yardline, C. Sweeting return 7 yards to the MILL43 (Ryan O'Donnell). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 3 yards, TOP 00:56 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill43 | SETON HILL drive start at 03:44. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Mill43 | C. Sweeting rush for 2 yards to the MILL41 (Sean Dugan;Tanner Dean). |
| Shu | 2-8 | at Mill41 | Evan Byrd rush for 2 yards to the MILL39 (M. Faughnan). |
| Shu | 3-6 | at Mill39 | C. Strong pass incomplete to Evan Byrd (Trejon Dinkins), PENALTY SHU holding declined. |
| Shu | 4-6 | at Mill39 | C. Strong pass incomplete to M. Williams. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 4 yards, TOP 01:16 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill39 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 02:28. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill39 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Nii Kotei Nikoi. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill39 | PENALTY MILL false start 5 yards to the MILL34. |
| Mill | 2-15 | at Mill34 | Collin Shank pass complete to Xavier Jenkins for 9 yards to the MILL43 (Malik Scott). |
| Mill | 3-6 | at Mill43 | Collin Shank pass complete to Phil Overton for 21 yards to the SHU36, 1ST DOWN MILL (Brent Leone). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu36 | Phil Overton rush for loss of 1 yard to the SHU37 (Tyler Affa). |
| Mill | 2-11 | at Shu37 | Collin Shank pass complete to Nii Kotei Nikoi for 4 yards to the SHU33 (Brent Leone). |
| Mill | 3-7 | at Shu33 | Collin Shank pass incomplete to Xavier Jenkins. |
| Mill | 4-7 | at Shu33 | Timeout Millersville, clock 00:37. |
| Mill | 4-7 | at Shu33 | Collin Shank pass complete to Kevin Wiggins for 33 yards to the SHU0, 1ST DOWN MILL, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:30. |
| | | Joey Farley kick attempt good. |
| | | Millersville 45, Seton Hill 38 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 61 yards, TOP 02:03 |
| | | Tyler Reiman kickoff 50 yards to the SHU15, Malik Scott return 0 yards to the SHU15 (Trejon Dinkins). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu15 | SETON HILL drive start at 00:25. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu15 | C. Strong pass complete to Kurt Adkins for 7 yards to the SHU22 (Cameron Boykin). |
| Shu | 2-3 | at Shu22 | Timeout Seton Hill, clock 00:17. |
| Shu | 2-3 | at Shu22 | C. Strong pass complete to Michael Elardo for 12 yards to the SHU34, 1ST DOWN SHU (B. Sherman). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu34 | C. Strong pass intercepted by Colin Suhr at the MILL41, Colin Suhr return 11 yards to the SHU48. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 19 yards, TOP 00:19 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu48 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 00:06. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Shu48 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the SHU49. |
| Mill | 2-11 | at Shu49 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:06 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Millersville 45, Seton Hill 38 |